top of page

Come Experience Old Florida Charm
in the Heart of Islamorada

  • 7 Guests

  • 4 Bedrooms

  • 3 Full Baths

  • Private Dock

  • Sunset   

  • Half Acre Oasis   

  • Pool & Jacuzzi

  • Boat Slip

  • Private Parking

  • Basketball Court

  • Tiki Bar

  • Waterfront

You don’t want to miss this! The Butterfly House is a waterfront property offering amazing sunsets from your private dock. The house is nestled in a lush, fenced estate next door to the world-famous Lorelei Restaurant. Enjoy your private pool, jacuzzi, tiki bar, dock, basketball court and much more. Perfect for families and comfortably hosts up to 7 guests. Book now to create memories that will last a lifetime.

ool, jacuzzi, tiki bar, and main house at Butterfly House Islamorada

Built in the 1940’s, it is truly a Keys style house complete with original Dade County Pine walls. Both charming and comfortably rustic. The main house has 3 bedrooms & 2 full baths. The back cottage is a 1 bedroom & 1 full bath. With unrivaled sunsets, easy access to restaurants, shopping, fishing, reefs & Islamorada sandbar, everything you could want would be yours for a magical relaxing vacation in paradise!

Living room with original Dade County Pine walls at Butterfly House Islamorada

Many people ask why we’re called the “Butterfly House.” In the 1990s, a previous owner used the house as a butterfly sanctuary and bird rehabilitation center. What is now the fountain used to be a chicken wired gazebo filled with hundreds of butterflies!
Sadly, Hurricane Irma took out the gazebo in 2017. However, we’ve honored its history by keeping the name Butterfly House 🦋

Butterfly House-Photos#-54.jpg
Butterfly House Gazeebo.jpg
bottom of page